We’ve done a lot of taste tests since launching Long Story Short with Megan and Wendy but you’ve never seen one quite like this from us. It’s our first blind taste test and we’re finally putting an end to the holiday question that has haunted us since 2014. Who makes the better peppermint cookie? Oreo vs. Joe Joe?
Megan says Oreo and Wendy says it’s Trader Joe’s Candy Cane Joe-Joe.
Here’s what we know for sure: Oreo knows how to do Oreo. Sure, there have been some losers like Red Velvet and S’mores but how does their peppermint version stand up? Will it land with their crazy flavors or somewhere amongst the classics?
And Trader Joe’s? Yes, the grocery chain makes an Oreo knock-off that is a fan favorite but will the Candy Cane Joe-Joe even compare to the 103 year old tradition of Oreo?
We had fun making this blind Oreo vs. Joe Joe taste test. Watch the video below and leave us a comment either here on the blog or on the video and let us know what we should try next.