Settle in folks, because this is a long one! We spend a lot of time talking about the stuff we love and use regularly, but what about those products that get shoved to the back of our makeup drawers, collecting dust? I have gone through a lot of disappointing makeup products, and even more disappointing is the fact that I had tossed a lot of it before we filmed this because I know there’s more!
Disappointing Makeup – It’s Not Bad, It’s Just Not For Us
A little disclaimer that we can’t help but post: These products aren’t inherently BAD, they were just bad for us. Everyone wants different things, uses their makeup differently and has different makeup skills. Perhaps you love something that we just didn’t. That’s cool! This is just makeup here, people. It’s one of the few places I’m comfortable saying we can agree to disagree.
Makeup We Were Disappointed By
- Revlon Ultimate All in One Mascara
- Revlon Volume and Length Mascara
- Tarte Lights, Camera, Flashes
- L’Oreal Voluminous Carbon Black
- Covergirl Supersizer Fibers
- Maybelline Color Molten Eyeshadow
- Covergirl Eyeshadow Quad
- Wet ‘N Wild Illuminating Palette
- L’Oreal Infallible ProMatte Gloss
- Maybelline Blushed Nudes Eyeshadow Palette
- Up&Up Makeup Sponge
- Maybelline Master Kajal Cream Kohl Eyeliner
- Hawaiian Tropic Lip Balm
- L’Oreal Magic Perfecting Base
- Nivea Mens Shave Balm
- L’Oreal Magic De-Crease Eye Primer
- LUSH Mint Julips Lip Scrub
It’s Not all Bad News
Since we do feel a little guilty baring our true feelings about these guys, check out our August favorites video for a dose of positivity! Have you purchased anything lately that just didn’t turn out to be what you had hoped it would be? Let us know in the comments what we should stay away from!
Beauty Products We Love
We love to chat beauty! Check of our favorite posts about makeup!
Talk Beauty with Megan and Wendy
We’re Your New Best Friends
Hi, we’re Megan and Wendy your midlife besties! Join us on Patreon every Monday where we’re talking everyday life, pop culture, and more!
You can also find us on “Girls Gone Hallmark” on Tuesdays and Thursdays where we review new and fan-favorite Hallmark movies and ask the question: Did you see that?

Oh my gosh! I LOVE L’Oreal’s Carbon Black Mascara….for years! But, I do find I don’t like it as much until I’ve used it for a couple weeks – weird I know…it must thicken or something…I’ve never noticed it being dry so maybe you got a bad batch??
Maybe it was a bad batch because it was bone dry! Thanks so much for weighing in. Maybe I’ll give it another try. – Wendy
Thanks for sharing your experience! Great post and video.
http://wherefitnessmeetsbeauty.net/fall-wardrobe-essentials/
xo!